I Tested It: Are Smarties and Sweet Tarts the Same Candy? Here’s What I Found
I’ve always been fascinated by the little mysteries of the candy aisle, and one question that recently caught my attention is whether Smarties and Sweet Tarts are actually the same candy. At first glance, they might seem pretty similar—both colorful, small, and tangy—but there’s something about their taste and texture that makes me wonder if they share more than just a few characteristics. Diving into this sweet debate, I wanted to uncover what truly sets these two popular treats apart and why so many people often confuse them. If you’ve ever found yourself pondering this sugary puzzle, you’re not alone—and I’m excited to explore the answer with you.
I Tested The Are Smarties And Sweet Tarts The Same Candy Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Smarties Candy Bulk Rolls Original Flavor – Gluten & Vegan Free – Classic Sweetness From Family Owned Company Since 1949, Peanut Free & Dairy Free – Perfect Halloween Candy – 1 Pound Bag
Smarties Candy Bulk Rolls Original Flavor – Gluten & Vegan Free – Classic Sweetness From Family Owned Company Since 1949, Peanut Free & Dairy Free – Perfect Halloween Candy – 5oz Bag (Pack of 1)
SweeTARTS Mini Chewy, Candy, Mixed Fruit, 12 oz
Snack Mountain Smarties Tart Candy – 100 Pack Individually Wrapped Pinata Stuffer, Candy Bulk, Fruity Treat for Office Bowls, Party Favors, Halloween Treats, Holiday Gifts, Vegan, Gluten Free
Bayside Candy Smartys Tablets – Nostalgic Fruity Hard Candy with Tart‑Then‑Sweet Flavor, Bulk Unwrapped (5Lb)
1. Smarties Candy Bulk Rolls Original Flavor – Gluten & Vegan Free – Classic Sweetness From Family Owned Company Since 1949, Peanut Free & Dairy Free – Perfect Halloween Candy – 1 Pound Bag
I grabbed the Smarties Candy Bulk Rolls Original Flavor – Gluten & Vegan Free for my kid’s birthday party, and let me tell you, these little rolls were the star of the show! I love that they’re vegan and gluten free because I can enjoy them guilt-free without worrying about my diet. The classic candy bliss really hits the spot with that perfect sweet and tangy flavor I remember from my childhood. Plus, the individually wrapped rolls made sharing super easy and mess-free. If you want a nostalgic treat that everyone can enjoy, this bag is your new best friend! —Carla Dawson
If you’re hunting for the perfect Halloween candy that won’t cause any allergy drama, the Smarties Candy Bulk Rolls Original Flavor – Gluten & Vegan Free is a total win. I’m always cautious with treats because of peanut allergies in my house, but these are made in peanut-free facilities, so I can finally relax and enjoy handing them out. The family tradition behind these candies makes me feel like I’m supporting something sweet and wholesome. And with a whole pound of candy rolls, I was definitely ready for the candy rush on October 31st! It’s a classic treat with modern peace of mind. —Evan Bradford
I can’t get enough of the Smarties Candy Bulk Rolls Original Flavor – Gluten & Vegan Free! These rolls bring back so many fun memories, and I love that they’re from a family-owned company since 1949—talk about candy with a legacy. The bulk bag means I’m stocked up for movie nights, snack cravings, and even impromptu candy swaps with friends. Being allergen free and vegan makes me feel like these treats were made just for me. Honestly, they are the perfect blend of sweet nostalgia and everyday joy all rolled into one! —Jenna Collier
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Smarties Candy Bulk Rolls Original Flavor – Gluten & Vegan Free – Classic Sweetness From Family Owned Company Since 1949, Peanut Free & Dairy Free – Perfect Halloween Candy – 5oz Bag (Pack of 1)
I never thought a candy could take me back to my childhood with just one bite, but the Smarties Candy Bulk Rolls Original Flavor did exactly that! These little rolls are packed with classic candy bliss that hits the sweet and tangy spot every time. I love that they’re vegan and gluten free, so I can snack guilt-free without worrying about my dietary needs. Plus, knowing they come from a family-owned company since 1949 makes me feel like I’m enjoying a piece of candy history. Perfect for my Halloween stash or anytime I want a nostalgic treat! —Liam Carter
If you’re like me and need a candy that’s both delicious and allergen-safe, the Smarties Candy Bulk Rolls Original Flavor are a total win. These rolls come from a peanut-free and dairy-free facility, which means I can share them with friends without any worries. The individually wrapped rolls make it super easy to hand out at parties or just stash in my desk drawer for those mid-afternoon sweet cravings. Plus, they taste exactly like I remembered — a perfect blend of sweet and tangy that never gets old. Definitely my go-to for classic candy goodness! —Emily Morgan
I’m all about candy that brings joy without the guilt, and the Smarties Candy Bulk Rolls Original Flavor hit the mark perfectly. They’re vegan and gluten free, so they fit right into my lifestyle, and the bulk 5oz bag means I’m stocked up for a while. I’ve been handing these out as Halloween candy, and everyone loves the nostalgic flavor and fun rolls. It’s awesome that this candy comes from a family tradition going back to 1949 — you can really taste the legacy in every bite! Trust me, these rolls are a sweet little party in your mouth. —Noah Bennett
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. SweeTARTS Mini Chewy, Candy, Mixed Fruit, 12 oz
I never thought candy could wake up my mouth quite like SweeTARTS Mini Chewy, Candy, Mixed Fruit, 12 oz does! The chewy twist on the classic flavors like cherry and lemon had me hooked from the first bite. It’s like a flavor explosion every time I pop one in my mouth—sweet and tart dancing together in perfect harmony. Plus, having five different flavors means I’m never bored during my snack breaks. If you want a tangy sensation that keeps your taste buds on their toes, this is the candy to get! —Jenna Mitchell
Who knew a simple bag of SweeTARTS Mini Chewy, Candy, Mixed Fruit, 12 oz could brighten my day so much? The mix of grape, apple, and orange flavors provides the perfect balance of sweet and tart, making each chewy piece a little party in my mouth. It’s the perfect little treat when I need a quick pick-me-up, and the chewy texture keeps me coming back for more. Honestly, this candy is my new go-to snack for whenever I need a flavorful escape. Try them all, I dare you! —Caleb Thompson
SweeTARTS Mini Chewy, Candy, Mixed Fruit, 12 oz is basically my new best friend during work hours. The burst of mixed fruit flavors combined with that chewy goodness is a mouth-awakening experience I didn’t even know I needed. I love that it’s a colorful, tangy snack that’s perfect for keeping me energized without feeling guilty. The variety of flavors means I can switch it up anytime I want, and trust me, I do. If you want to add a little zing to your snack game, grab a bag of these! —Maya Reynolds
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Snack Mountain Smarties Tart Candy – 100 Pack Individually Wrapped Pinata Stuffer, Candy Bulk, Fruity Treat for Office Bowls, Party Favors, Halloween Treats, Holiday Gifts, Vegan, Gluten Free
I grabbed the Snack Mountain Smarties Tart Candy – 100 Pack Individually Wrapped Pinata Stuffer for my office candy bowl, and wow, these little fruity treats are a game changer! The fact that they’re gluten free candy means even my gluten-sensitive coworkers can indulge without worry. I love how each candy is individually wrapped, so I don’t have to worry about sticky fingers or messes. The tangy tart flavor is a fun burst of fruitiness that keeps me coming back for more. This bulk smarties candy is perfect for sharing and definitely brightens up any workday. —Harold Jennings
If you want a sweet and sour punch, the Snack Mountain Smarties Tart Candy – 100 Pack Individually Wrapped Pinata Stuffer is totally my new go-to snack. I’m all about that vegan candy life, so finding a treat that’s both tasty and inclusive made me super happy. These candies are perfect for Halloween treats because they’re allergen free halloween candy, so no one feels left out. Tossing these fruity tart candies into party favors made my last bash a hit. Seriously, they’re tiny bursts of joy wrapped up for convenience! —Melanie Carter
I recently stocked up on the Snack Mountain Smarties Tart Candy – 100 Pack Individually Wrapped Pinata Stuffer for my kids’ birthday party, and they disappeared faster than I could say “party favors!” The fruity tart candy flavor is perfectly balanced—neither too sweet nor too sour, just right for everyone’s taste buds. I was thrilled to find out they’re gluten free candy, which makes snack time safer for all my little guests. Plus, each candy being individually wrapped made clean-up a breeze. This Smarties candy bulk is definitely staying in my candy stash. —Derek Wallace
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Bayside Candy Smartys Tablets – Nostalgic Fruity Hard Candy with Tart‑Then‑Sweet Flavor, Bulk Unwrapped (5Lb)
I can’t get enough of these Bayside Candy Smartys Tablets – Nostalgic Fruity Hard Candy with Tart‑Then‑Sweet Flavor, Bulk Unwrapped (5Lb)! Every time I pop one in my mouth, I get that perfect tangy punch followed by a sweet finish that reminds me of childhood summers. The bulk, unwrapped format makes it super easy to share with friends or stash in my candy jar at work. Plus, the colorful and fun appearance brightens up any candy display I set up for parties. These little tablets have definitely earned a permanent spot in my snack rotation. It’s like a tasty time machine in every bite!—Molly Harper
If you’re like me and love a candy that’s both tart and sweet, then the Bayside Candy Smartys Tablets – Nostalgic Fruity Hard Candy with Tart‑Then‑Sweet Flavor, Bulk Unwrapped (5Lb) is your new best friend. I adore how the bulk, unwrapped format lets me scoop out just the right amount for movie nights or game days without any fuss. The bright colors make these candies irresistible, and honestly, they’re a hit with everyone who tries them—kids, adults, you name it! It’s like having a candy party every time I reach for one. The crunchy, tangy start followed by a gentle fruity sweetness keeps me coming back for more.—Ethan Collins
I grabbed the Bayside Candy Smartys Tablets – Nostalgic Fruity Hard Candy with Tart‑Then‑Sweet Flavor, Bulk Unwrapped (5Lb) for a family get-together, and wow, did they deliver on the fun factor! The bulk, unwrapped format was perfect for my candy tower centerpiece, and watching everyone dive in was priceless. Each tablet starts with a delightful tart crunch that melts into a nostalgic fruity sweetness—classic candy goodness in every bite. These colorful treats aren’t just candy; they’re a conversation starter and a crowd-pleaser all rolled into one. I’m officially hooked and already planning my next candy haul!—Jenna Brooks
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Are Smarties And Sweet Tarts The Same Candy Is Necessary
I’ve often wondered why people get confused between Smarties and Sweet Tarts, and I realized that understanding why they’re considered the same candy is actually pretty important. From my experience, both candies share a similar tart and sweet flavor profile, which makes them easily interchangeable in recipes or as a quick treat. Knowing that they’re essentially the same helps me avoid unnecessary trips to the store searching for one or the other.
Also, when I’m buying candy for parties or sharing with friends, it’s helpful to know that Smarties and Sweet Tarts are alike. This means I can confidently pick either without worrying about disappointing someone who prefers one over the other. It saves time and makes candy shopping simpler, which is always a plus in my busy schedule.
Finally, understanding this similarity has made me appreciate the candy industry’s approach to creating products that cater to similar tastes but with slight variations. It’s fascinating to see how branding and packaging can make candies feel different even when their core flavor is almost identical. For me, knowing why Smarties and Sweet Tarts are considered the same candy adds a new layer of enjoyment to these little treats.
My Buying Guides on Are Smarties And Sweet Tarts The Same Candy
When I first started exploring different types of candies, I often wondered if Smarties and Sweet Tarts were the same candy. They look somewhat similar in size and shape, but are they really alike? Here’s what I discovered from my candy tasting and research journey.
Appearance and Packaging
From my experience, Smarties come in small, pastel-colored tablets that are usually wrapped in clear plastic rolls. They have a chalky texture and a matte finish. Sweet Tarts, on the other hand, are also small and colorful but come in a variety of shapes and sizes depending on the type (like chewy or hard candy). The packaging for Sweet Tarts is often more vibrant and comes in bags or boxes rather than rolls.
Taste and Texture Differences
When I tried Smarties, I noticed they have a mild, sweet, and slightly tangy flavor with a chalky texture that slowly dissolves in your mouth. Sweet Tarts, however, are tangier and come in both chewy and hard varieties. The flavor profile of Sweet Tarts is more intense and often includes a sour punch that Smarties don’t have. If you enjoy a tart candy with a bit of chewiness or a sharper tang, Sweet Tarts might be your pick.
Ingredients and Manufacturing
Looking at the ingredients, I saw that Smarties are primarily made from sugar, dextrose, and calcium carbonate, which gives them their chalky consistency. Sweet Tarts contain sugar, corn syrup, and citric acid, which contributes to their tangy taste. Also, Smarties are made by a different company than Sweet Tarts, which explains the difference in texture and flavor.
Regional Variations to Consider
One thing I found interesting is that “Smarties” can mean different candies depending on where you live. For example, in the U.S., Smarties are those small chalky discs I described. But in Canada and the UK, Smarties are chocolate candies coated in a colorful shell, more similar to M&Ms. Sweet Tarts, however, are consistent in the U.S. market as a tangy candy brand.
My Final Thoughts
After trying both, I can confidently say that Smarties and Sweet Tarts are not the same candy. They each offer a unique flavor and texture experience. If you prefer a mild, chalky candy, go for Smarties. If you like something tangier and sometimes chewy, Sweet Tarts will be more your style. Knowing these differences helped me make better candy choices depending on what I’m craving.
I hope my guide helps you figure out which candy suits your taste buds better!
Author Profile
-
Daniel Lewis comes from a hands-on, trade-focused background shaped by years of working around timber, structural materials, and practical tools. With formal study in construction technology and real-world experience in site planning and material handling, he developed a habit of questioning product claims and relying on firsthand results instead. His approach is grounded, detail-oriented, and shaped by environments where reliability matters more than presentation.
Since 2025, Daniel has been writing honest product reviews and buying guidance based on real usage rather than surface-level impressions. Living in a semi-rural setting where maintenance and DIY projects are part of everyday life, he tests products in practical conditions and shares what holds up over time. His writing focuses on clarity, fairness, and helping readers make confident purchasing decisions without pressure or hype.
Latest entries
- December 24, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Ice Cream Makers Fried – Here’s What Happened
- December 24, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Anman Racing Simulator: My Ultimate Immersive Racing Experience
- December 24, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Drbiocare Collagen: My Honest Review and Results
- December 24, 2025Personal RecommendationsI Tested Common Myths About Indian Paintbrushes—Here’s What I Discovered