Should I Remove Old Hardwood Before Installing Vinyl Plank? Here’s What You Need to Know!

AvatarByMahlon Boehs General Wood Topics

When it comes to upgrading your flooring, the decision to install vinyl plank over existing hardwood can be both exciting and daunting. Many homeowners find themselves grappling with the question: should I remove old hardwood before installing vinyl plank? This seemingly simple inquiry opens the door to a myriad of considerations, from the structural integrity of your floors to the aesthetic appeal of your space. As you embark on this transformative journey, understanding the implications of your flooring choices will not only enhance your home’s beauty but also its value.

In the world of flooring, the choice between removing old hardwood or laying vinyl plank over it is often a matter of personal preference and practical necessity. While some may argue that removing the old flooring is essential for achieving a flawless finish, others may find that leaving it in place can save time, money, and effort. Factors such as the condition of the hardwood, the height of the new flooring, and potential moisture issues all play pivotal roles in this decision-making process.

Moreover, the installation method you choose can greatly influence the final outcome of your flooring project. Whether you opt for a floating installation or glue-down method, understanding the pros and cons of each approach will help you make an informed decision. As we delve deeper into this topic, we’ll explore the benefits and drawbacks of both

Assessing the Condition of Old Hardwood

When considering whether to remove old hardwood flooring before installing vinyl plank, it’s essential to assess the condition of the existing hardwood. If the hardwood is in good condition, it can serve as a solid underlayment for the new flooring. However, if there are significant issues, removal may be necessary.

Factors to evaluate include:

  • Warping or Buckling: Check for any signs of warping, which could affect the installation of vinyl plank.
  • Moisture Damage: Look for areas with water damage or mold growth, as these can compromise the integrity of the new flooring.
  • Surface Flatness: The existing hardwood should be level; uneven surfaces can lead to problems with the vinyl plank installation.

Benefits of Removing Old Hardwood

While it may be tempting to install vinyl plank over existing hardwood, there are several benefits to removing the old flooring:

  • Improved Stability: Removing the old hardwood ensures a stable and even surface for the vinyl planks, reducing the risk of movement or creaking.
  • Moisture Control: It allows for a thorough inspection and treatment of any moisture issues beneath the hardwood.
  • Better Adhesion: New vinyl flooring may adhere better to a clean, solid surface rather than an old, potentially uneven hardwood floor.
  • Enhanced Soundproofing: Removing the hardwood can provide an opportunity to add soundproofing materials before installing the vinyl.

When to Keep the Old Hardwood

In some cases, it may be advantageous to leave the old hardwood in place:

  • Cost-Effectiveness: Removing hardwood can be labor-intensive and costly. Keeping it can save money.
  • Preservation of Original Features: If the hardwood is original to the home and in decent condition, preserving it can enhance the property’s value and aesthetics.
  • Time Efficiency: Skipping the removal process can significantly reduce project time, allowing for quicker completion.

Installation Considerations

If you decide to install vinyl plank over old hardwood, consider the following:

  • Underlayment: Use an appropriate underlayment to provide cushioning and sound insulation.
  • Expansion Gaps: Ensure to leave expansion gaps around the perimeter of the room to accommodate any movement.
  • Height Concerns: Be aware of the increased height from adding vinyl over hardwood, which may affect door clearances.
Factor Remove Hardwood Keep Hardwood
Cost Higher Lower
Installation Time Longer Shorter
Surface Stability Better Potential Issues
Moisture Control Improved Risk of Damage

Evaluating these factors will guide you in making an informed decision on whether to remove old hardwood before installing vinyl plank flooring.

Considerations for Removing Old Hardwood

When contemplating whether to remove old hardwood flooring before installing vinyl plank flooring, several factors need to be assessed.

  • Condition of the Hardwood: Inspect the existing hardwood for signs of damage, such as warping, buckling, or severe wear. If the hardwood is in poor condition, it may be beneficial to remove it to ensure a stable and level base for the vinyl plank.
  • Height Considerations: Installing vinyl plank over existing hardwood can increase the floor height, potentially affecting transitions to other rooms, door clearances, and baseboard heights. Measure the current height of your flooring and consider the implications of adding additional layers.
  • Moisture Issues: Evaluate the environment for moisture levels. If the hardwood is in a damp area, moisture could seep through to the vinyl, leading to mold or degradation over time. Removing the hardwood allows for better moisture control and inspection of the subfloor.
  • Warranty Conditions: Review the warranty for the new vinyl plank flooring. Some manufacturers may require the removal of existing flooring to maintain warranty validity. Always check the guidelines provided by the manufacturer.

Advantages of Keeping Old Hardwood

There are several benefits to leaving the old hardwood floor in place when installing vinyl plank flooring.

  • Cost Savings: Keeping the existing hardwood can reduce labor and disposal costs associated with removal.
  • Insulation: Hardwood provides additional insulation, which can enhance the thermal properties of the floor.
  • Sound Dampening: Hardwood can help reduce sound transmission between floors, creating a quieter environment.

Installation Techniques for Vinyl Plank over Hardwood

If you decide to install vinyl plank over old hardwood, certain techniques and preparations should be undertaken to ensure a successful installation.

  • Clean the Surface: Thoroughly clean the hardwood floor to remove any dust, dirt, or debris that could affect adhesion.
  • Level the Floor: Use a leveling compound to fill in any gaps or low spots on the hardwood to create a smooth surface for the vinyl.
  • Underlayment: Consider using an underlayment that provides cushioning and moisture barrier properties. This can enhance comfort and prolong the life of the vinyl.
  • Floating Installation: Opt for a floating installation method, which allows the vinyl to expand and contract without being glued down. This is particularly effective over hardwood.

Potential Drawbacks of Keeping Old Hardwood

While there are advantages to retaining the old hardwood, some drawbacks should also be considered.

  • Potential for Uneven Surfaces: If the hardwood is not perfectly level, it could lead to an uneven installation of the vinyl plank, resulting in a compromised aesthetic and durability.
  • Maintenance Concerns: Old hardwood may require maintenance, and its presence could complicate future repairs or modifications to the flooring.
  • Odor and Allergen Issues: Older hardwood may harbor odors or allergens, which could be a concern in certain living environments, especially if pets or moisture exposure has been an issue.

Best Practices

When deciding whether to remove old hardwood flooring before installing vinyl plank, weigh the pros and cons carefully. Assess the condition of the hardwood, consider the installation environment, and review warranty stipulations. Taking these factors into account will guide you towards the best decision for your flooring project.

Expert Insights on Removing Old Hardwood Before Installing Vinyl Plank

Jessica Harmon (Flooring Specialist, Home Renovation Magazine). “While it is possible to install vinyl plank flooring over old hardwood, it is often recommended to remove the hardwood first. This ensures a level surface, reduces the risk of moisture issues, and allows for better adhesion of the vinyl planks.”

Michael Chen (Certified Flooring Installer, National Flooring Association). “Removing old hardwood can prevent complications such as warping and unevenness in the new vinyl flooring. It is crucial to address any underlying issues with the hardwood before proceeding with the installation of vinyl planks.”

Linda Patel (Home Improvement Consultant, DIY Network). “If the hardwood is in good condition and securely fastened, you might consider leaving it in place. However, for the best long-term results, removing the hardwood allows for a more stable and reliable installation of vinyl planks.”

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Should I remove old hardwood before installing vinyl plank?
It is not necessary to remove old hardwood before installing vinyl plank, as long as the hardwood is in good condition and properly secured. However, removing it can provide a more level surface and may enhance the overall appearance.

What are the benefits of leaving old hardwood in place?
Leaving old hardwood in place can save time and labor costs, as well as minimize waste. It can also provide additional insulation and sound dampening, which may be beneficial in certain environments.

Are there any drawbacks to installing vinyl plank over old hardwood?
Installing vinyl plank over old hardwood may result in an uneven surface if the hardwood is warped or damaged. Additionally, moisture issues can arise if the hardwood absorbs moisture, potentially affecting the vinyl plank installation.

What preparation is needed if I decide to keep the old hardwood?
If you choose to keep the old hardwood, ensure it is clean, dry, and free of debris. Check for any loose boards or nails and secure them to create a stable base for the vinyl plank installation.

Can I install vinyl plank over engineered hardwood?
Yes, you can install vinyl plank over engineered hardwood, provided it is in good condition and properly secured. Ensure that the surface is level and free from moisture before proceeding with the installation.

What should I do if the old hardwood is damaged or uneven?
If the old hardwood is damaged or uneven, it is advisable to remove it to ensure a proper installation of the vinyl plank. Repairing or leveling the surface may not provide the desired results and could lead to future issues.
the decision to remove old hardwood flooring before installing vinyl plank flooring depends on several factors, including the condition of the existing hardwood, the type of vinyl plank being installed, and the desired outcome of the renovation. If the hardwood is in good condition, it may be left in place, providing a stable base for the new flooring. However, if the hardwood is damaged, uneven, or poses potential issues such as moisture retention, removal may be the best option to ensure a successful installation.

Additionally, homeowners should consider the thickness of the vinyl plank flooring and the overall height of the finished floor. Installing vinyl over existing hardwood can raise the floor height, which may affect door clearances and transitions to other rooms. Therefore, it is essential to assess these factors before making a final decision.

Ultimately, consulting with a flooring professional can provide valuable insights tailored to specific situations. They can help evaluate the condition of the hardwood and recommend the most appropriate course of action, ensuring that the new vinyl plank flooring is installed correctly and performs well over time.

Author Profile

Avatar
Mahlon Boehs
Mahlon Boehs is a seasoned entrepreneur and industry expert with a deep understanding of wood truss manufacturing and construction materials. As the President of Timberlake TrussWorks, LLC, Mahlon played a pivotal role in shaping the company’s reputation for quality and precision. His leadership ensured that each truss met rigorous structural standards, providing builders with dependable components essential to their projects.

Beginning in 2025, Mahlon Boehs has shifted his focus to education and knowledge-sharing through an informative blog dedicated to wood truss manufacturing. Drawing from his extensive experience in the field, he provides in-depth insights into truss design, material selection, and construction techniques. This blog serves as a valuable resource for builders, contractors, and homeowners seeking practical guidance on truss systems and structural integrity.